{
  "format": "sutro-pr142-fresh-independent-audit-v1",
  "status": "PASS",
  "checked_utc": "2026-11-02T04:27:47.983667+00:00",
  "reviewed_head": "5cd8a6502eb01263fe8b1333c49d2ac4eaaf8fa2",
  "base_head": "09979ba2ce5bba4ef80432ec5004b27686541bdf",
  "source_sha256": "02755ca6031242b0ef29ded5ba2f4f78ee7e592e120694edb3a4d2ed65f9d010",
  "source_bytes": 20429,
  "function": "hybrid_d4",
  "difficulty": 4,
  "scorer_sha256": "1bc6d8d96a776565bc70f3ccdb91be7de57187d4495b2b0437fac98f5e120064",
  "runner_sha256": "1180b843cf6c32414774da90c835a8b7298d2db8719989237a793ca1c62a10ab",
  "launch_guard_sha256": "350d01dc0140cf7150ce74c349f3c4e7cf5d8224f4c58f479b0c2acb0dc18306",
  "measurement_plan_sha256": "c5198ef263472dbda455c2cb50fd7d0e4f2d03480f2748b48232ff72246232be",
  "controller_status_sha256": "e87d98f8547b781db6d24c819b3c9537f2189c5168d0204865c7cc7d10deafce",
  "controller_log_sha256": "07f47742dfd83d575650e80e7a863447aaee5e760d80939a675cc8a3a4dcf18e",
  "owned_app_provenance_sha256": "282acf7dc775679a530cea499ea45dba86ec407e33f4d36416a3d525b2f5dbc4",
  "apps_before_inventory_sha256": "70a5d1d320756e9773a3a537ae072d536de397f89dfa717c31f13706c2ae8b34",
  "preflight_checks": {
    "exact_reviewed_head": true,
    "exact_base": true,
    "exact_source_identity": true,
    "independent_snapshot_source_identity": true,
    "source_at_exact_Git_head": true,
    "canonical_scorer": true,
    "canonical_runner": true,
    "guard_exact": true,
    "plan_pin": true,
    "controller_terminal_success": true,
    "no_group_deadline": true,
    "plan_before_launch": true,
    "source_frozen_and_initial_group": true,
    "fixed_three_stock_energy": true,
    "outcomes_retained_and_no_replacement": true,
    "controller_command_exact_plan": true,
    "exact_retained_run_inventory": true,
    "canonical_command_defaults": true,
    "input_pin:pr142/source/mnist-a100/submissions/hybrid-walk-220-d4-20261101/submission.py": true,
    "input_pin:canonical/mnist.py": true,
    "input_pin:canonical/run_modal.py": true,
    "input_pin:saved_record_audit.py": true,
    "input_pin:launch_frozen_review.py": true,
    "input_pin:pr142/snapshot-manifest.json": true,
    "owned_app_ids_from_initialized_log": true,
    "owned_app_stop_marker": true,
    "owned_app_rows_exact_ids": true,
    "owned_app_rows_stopped_zero": true,
    "provenance_before_controller_close": true,
    "within_external_wall_limit": true
  },
  "passed_runs": 3,
  "required_passed_runs": 3,
  "timed_calls": 45,
  "median_ranked_ms": 22.069657387849297,
  "energy_valid_runs": 3,
  "median_energy_mj": 2259.293532151003,
  "energy_separate_from_score": true,
  "mnist_correct": 322819,
  "mnist_total": 330000,
  "pooled_mnist_error_pct_descriptive": 2.1760606060606063,
  "pooled_scope": "Each full run separately qualifies; pooled counts describe retained data and are not an alternative qualification gate.",
  "distinct_energy_device_ids": 3,
  "hardware_models": [
    "NVIDIA A100-SXM4-80GB"
  ],
  "baseline": {
    "verification_path": "mnist-a100/submissions/codesign-d4-d5-20261024/evidence/reviewer-20261025/d4/verification.json",
    "verification_sha256": "864d6e64a6d1ceb69ce8935f6f5a7ac9c6266ba3e5a7ff2acfe7c45acbeb363c",
    "median_ranked_ms": 25.26462687854491,
    "candidate_is_faster": true,
    "speedup_ratio": 1.1447675165294882,
    "time_reduction_pct": 12.646018902455381,
    "scope": "Full-precision comparison of separately measured record groups; no paired-hardware causal speed or energy claim."
  },
  "execution_scope": {
    "logical_returned_runs": 3,
    "CUDA_startup_banner_count": 5,
    "explicit_preemption_log_lines": 0,
    "interpretation": "Five CUDA startup banners appear for three returned logical runs. No explicit preemption line is present; cause and container-attempt mapping cannot be established from these logs. All first returned logical outcomes are retained; no maintainer-launched replacement is recorded. Do not claim that no platform restart/retry occurred.",
    "owned_apps_count": 1,
    "owned_app_stopped_zero": true,
    "controller_elapsed_seconds": 508.8481945991516
  },
  "runs": [
    {
      "run": 1,
      "raw_file": "run-1.json",
      "raw_sha256": "67df1e4f31212721c2acb24a707711bba73280dc8cb86e67f13243be0d291f80",
      "stdout_bytes": 1641,
      "stdout_sha256": "6cf47f72490b7d43200d7951d13d39e523a1e843212419f6690aaaef770dc395",
      "stderr_bytes": 3536,
      "stderr_sha256": "741f0f295921aed5a9f38d47ae548353d3a1b5b9eb667aff824e9ded396f482d",
      "header_checks": {
        "successful_return": true,
        "exact_source": true,
        "exact_entrypoint": true,
        "canonical_version": true,
        "sandboxed": true,
        "correct_band": true,
        "A100_80GB": true,
        "canonical_image_torch": true
      },
      "score_passed": true,
      "literal_checks": {
        "exact15calls": true,
        "exact11MNIST": true,
        "exact4foreign": true,
        "only_declared_datasets": true,
        "foreign_valid": true,
        "call1_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call2_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call3_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call4_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call5_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call6_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call7_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call8_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call9_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call10_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call11_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call12_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call13_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call14_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call15_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "mnist_accuracy": true,
        "mnist_per_draw": true,
        "mnist_trimmed_parent_clock": true,
        "mnist_dispersion": true,
        "holdout_accuracy": true,
        "holdout_per_draw": true,
        "holdout_trimmed_parent_clock": true,
        "holdout_dispersion": true
      },
      "parity_checks": {
        "literal_rank_vs_canonical": true,
        "stored_rank_exact": true,
        "stored_problems_exact": true,
        "stored_summary_exact": true,
        "literal_acceptance_vs_canonical": true
      },
      "canonical_problems": [],
      "ranked_ms": 22.069657387849297,
      "groups": {
        "mnist": {
          "correct": 107514,
          "total": 110000,
          "required_correct": 107470,
          "accuracy_margin_labels": 44,
          "accuracy_pct": 97.74000000000001,
          "per_draw_floor_correct": 9620,
          "weakest_correct": 9750,
          "reported_ms_mean": 18.708759134465996,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms_mean": 22.263201183521627,
          "parent_floor_ms": 22.069657387849297,
          "floor_applied": true,
          "ranked_group_ms": 22.069657387849297,
          "median_reported_ms": 18.700288772583008,
          "min_reported_ms": 18.663423538208008,
          "max_reported_ms": 18.787328720092773,
          "trimmed_kept_group_indices": [
            2,
            1,
            9,
            5,
            3,
            4,
            6,
            8,
            10
          ],
          "trimmed_reported_mean_ms": 18.698922475179035,
          "trimmed_parent_less_protocol_mean_ms": 22.14208177980236
        },
        "holdout": {
          "correct": 38753,
          "total": 40000,
          "required_correct": 6000,
          "accuracy_margin_labels": 32753,
          "accuracy_pct": 96.88250000000001,
          "per_draw_floor_correct": null,
          "weakest_correct": 9676,
          "reported_ms_mean": 18.719231605529785,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms_mean": 22.189984251072303,
          "parent_floor_ms": 21.996388093044654,
          "floor_applied": true,
          "ranked_group_ms": 21.996388093044654,
          "median_reported_ms": 18.718719482421875,
          "min_reported_ms": 18.685951232910156,
          "max_reported_ms": 18.753536224365234,
          "trimmed_kept_group_indices": [
            2,
            1,
            4
          ],
          "trimmed_reported_mean_ms": 18.73032506306966,
          "trimmed_parent_less_protocol_mean_ms": 21.896844833668638
        }
      },
      "literal_calls": [
        {
          "index": 1,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.663423538208008,
          "parent_ms": 25.116056999998193,
          "correct": 9792,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 3.2415999973897414,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 21.87445700260845,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.211033464400444,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.331711769104004,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 2,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.719743728637695,
          "parent_ms": 24.973981999998784,
          "correct": 9774,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 3.099094997388505,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 21.87488700261028,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.155143273972584,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.35987186431885,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 3,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.699264526367188,
          "parent_ms": 24.883135999999695,
          "correct": 9781,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.8326074966983015,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 22.050528503301393,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.351263976934206,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.349632263183594,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 4,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.711551666259766,
          "parent_ms": 24.86629000000562,
          "correct": 9750,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.550761497045471,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 22.31552850296015,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.603976836700383,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.35577583312988,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 5,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.700288772583008,
          "parent_ms": 24.569995999996763,
          "correct": 9770,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.577640496701804,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 21.99235550329496,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.2920667307119515,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.350144386291504,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 6,
          "dataset": "kmnist",
          "ms": 18.726911544799805,
          "parent_ms": 24.842703999979676,
          "correct": 9695,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.9892679999135225,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 21.853436000066154,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.126524455266349,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.3634557723999,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 7,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.728960037231445,
          "parent_ms": 25.016310000012254,
          "correct": 9759,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.6428100000772474,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 22.373499999935007,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.6445399627035613,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.36448001861572,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 8,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.718719482421875,
          "parent_ms": 25.6502959999807,
          "correct": 9763,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.7918679999088454,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 22.858428000071854,
          "unexplained_ms": 4.139708517649979,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.35935974121094,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 9,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.694143295288086,
          "parent_ms": 25.37948700000925,
          "correct": 9797,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.9502670024047575,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 22.42921999760449,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.7350767023164053,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.34707164764404,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 10,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.693119049072266,
          "parent_ms": 24.989823999987948,
          "correct": 9778,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 3.0543289970428305,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 21.935495002945117,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.242375953872852,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.34655952453613,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 11,
          "dataset": "kmnist",
          "ms": 18.710527420043945,
          "parent_ms": 24.375937000002068,
          "correct": 9688,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.6956729993904673,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 21.6802640006116,
          "unexplained_ms": 2.9697365805676554,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.35526371002197,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 12,
          "dataset": "kmnist",
          "ms": 18.685951232910156,
          "parent_ms": 25.746314999992137,
          "correct": 9694,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.6769124967088374,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 23.0694025032833,
          "unexplained_ms": 4.383451270373143,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.34297561645508,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 13,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.679807662963867,
          "parent_ms": 24.834880000014437,
          "correct": 9789,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.402115497053046,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 22.43276450296139,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.7529568399975233,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.339903831481934,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 14,
          "dataset": "kmnist",
          "ms": 18.753536224365234,
          "parent_ms": 25.115002000006825,
          "correct": 9676,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.958167499678666,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 22.15683450032816,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.403298275962925,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.37676811218262,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 15,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.787328720092773,
          "parent_ms": 25.346829999989495,
          "correct": 9761,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.588780999544724,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 22.75804900044477,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.9707202803519976,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.39366436004639,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        }
      ],
      "energy_valid": true,
      "energy": {
        "valid": true,
        "checks": {
          "finite_nonnegative_windows": true,
          "exact_matmul": true,
          "reference_j_per_tflop": true,
          "reference_tflops": true,
          "idle_utilization_zero": true,
          "idle_contexts_at_most_one": true,
          "energy_correct_vector": true,
          "energy_call_times": true,
          "energy_dispersion": true,
          "positive_net_energy": true
        },
        "rebuilt_mj_per_call": 2287.3518885881012,
        "method_net_mj_before_control": 2303.0796056096992,
        "control_mj_per_call": 15.727717021598043,
        "reference_tflops": 18.220389455804348,
        "reference_j_per_tflop": 8.11488087977586,
        "energy_calls": 945,
        "energy_correct": 9240628,
        "energy_total": 9450000,
        "energy_median_ms": 15.220735549926758,
        "energy_window_names": [
          "idle 1",
          "reference",
          "idle 2",
          "control",
          "idle 3",
          "method",
          "idle 4"
        ],
        "parity_checks": {
          "canonical_stored_record_exact": true,
          "literal_mj_vs_canonical": true,
          "literal_validity_vs_canonical": true
        },
        "canonical_problems": [],
        "raw_window_sha256": "a5f3bb07f7e674402e04db0b812c02991c866684d2491f3bbf86e6169375f2fe"
      }
    },
    {
      "run": 2,
      "raw_file": "run-2.json",
      "raw_sha256": "432b1e0ecf5a04b9593a9ed8660c174aa8358033239b81b85a648af7589f87e5",
      "stdout_bytes": 1641,
      "stdout_sha256": "57e9c761b261f3b293cb17a0ed279e2b0fc065665fa0f4ccc5a9a1b7592f3a2c",
      "stderr_bytes": 3536,
      "stderr_sha256": "741f0f295921aed5a9f38d47ae548353d3a1b5b9eb667aff824e9ded396f482d",
      "header_checks": {
        "successful_return": true,
        "exact_source": true,
        "exact_entrypoint": true,
        "canonical_version": true,
        "sandboxed": true,
        "correct_band": true,
        "A100_80GB": true,
        "canonical_image_torch": true
      },
      "score_passed": true,
      "literal_checks": {
        "exact15calls": true,
        "exact11MNIST": true,
        "exact4foreign": true,
        "only_declared_datasets": true,
        "foreign_valid": true,
        "call1_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call2_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call3_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call4_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call5_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call6_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call7_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call8_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call9_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call10_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call11_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call12_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call13_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call14_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call15_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "mnist_accuracy": true,
        "mnist_per_draw": true,
        "mnist_trimmed_parent_clock": true,
        "mnist_dispersion": true,
        "holdout_accuracy": true,
        "holdout_per_draw": true,
        "holdout_trimmed_parent_clock": true,
        "holdout_dispersion": true
      },
      "parity_checks": {
        "literal_rank_vs_canonical": true,
        "stored_rank_exact": true,
        "stored_problems_exact": true,
        "stored_summary_exact": true,
        "literal_acceptance_vs_canonical": true
      },
      "canonical_problems": [],
      "ranked_ms": 22.018176942086633,
      "groups": {
        "mnist": {
          "correct": 107718,
          "total": 110000,
          "required_correct": 107470,
          "accuracy_margin_labels": 248,
          "accuracy_pct": 97.92545454545454,
          "per_draw_floor_correct": 9620,
          "weakest_correct": 9768,
          "reported_ms_mean": 18.704011570323598,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms_mean": 22.21169699993825,
          "parent_floor_ms": 22.018176942086633,
          "floor_applied": true,
          "ranked_group_ms": 22.018176942086633,
          "median_reported_ms": 18.702335357666016,
          "min_reported_ms": 18.672639846801758,
          "max_reported_ms": 18.740224838256836,
          "trimmed_kept_group_indices": [
            5,
            4,
            8,
            10,
            6,
            9,
            7,
            1,
            11
          ],
          "trimmed_reported_mean_ms": 18.704383850097656,
          "trimmed_parent_less_protocol_mean_ms": 22.12697944442374
        },
        "holdout": {
          "correct": 38645,
          "total": 40000,
          "required_correct": 6000,
          "accuracy_margin_labels": 32645,
          "accuracy_pct": 96.6125,
          "per_draw_floor_correct": null,
          "weakest_correct": 9648,
          "reported_ms_mean": 18.704895496368408,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms_mean": 22.126661374232697,
          "parent_floor_ms": 21.933136896750852,
          "floor_applied": true,
          "ranked_group_ms": 21.933136896750852,
          "median_reported_ms": 18.695167541503906,
          "min_reported_ms": 18.671615600585938,
          "max_reported_ms": 18.757631301879883,
          "trimmed_kept_group_indices": [
            3,
            4,
            2
          ],
          "trimmed_reported_mean_ms": 18.68731689453125,
          "trimmed_parent_less_protocol_mean_ms": 22.053979499145118
        }
      },
      "literal_calls": [
        {
          "index": 1,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.740224838256836,
          "parent_ms": 25.649990999994543,
          "correct": 9768,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 3.1790919970424696,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 22.470899002952073,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.7306741646952375,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.37011241912842,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 2,
          "dataset": "kmnist",
          "ms": 18.757631301879883,
          "parent_ms": 25.024063000003594,
          "correct": 9672,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.6793560005081645,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 22.34470699949543,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.5870756976155462,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.37881565093994,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 3,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.721792221069336,
          "parent_ms": 25.0763720000009,
          "correct": 9808,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.561062500510019,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 22.515309499490883,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.7935172784215467,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.36089611053467,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 4,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.682880401611328,
          "parent_ms": 25.36611499999708,
          "correct": 9791,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.6955724999808695,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 22.67054250001621,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.9876620984048827,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.341440200805664,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 5,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.68390464782715,
          "parent_ms": 24.610773999995672,
          "correct": 9800,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.7457734999813965,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 21.865000500014276,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.181095852187127,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.341952323913574,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 6,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.701311111450195,
          "parent_ms": 24.551233000011052,
          "correct": 9797,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.9535219994635327,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 21.59771100054752,
          "unexplained_ms": 2.8963998890973244,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.3506555557251,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 7,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.734079360961914,
          "parent_ms": 24.674438999994663,
          "correct": 9785,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.500010000150837,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 22.174428999843826,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.440349638881912,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.36703968048096,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 8,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.681856155395508,
          "parent_ms": 24.956209999999146,
          "correct": 9788,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.6220610001561226,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 22.334148999843023,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.6522928444475156,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.340928077697754,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 9,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.672639846801758,
          "parent_ms": 24.688460999982453,
          "correct": 9776,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.71116350034265,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 21.977297499639803,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.3046576528380456,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.33631992340088,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 10,
          "dataset": "kmnist",
          "ms": 18.712575912475586,
          "parent_ms": 24.967419999995855,
          "correct": 9652,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.7627704993981297,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 22.204649500597725,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.492073588122139,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.35628795623779,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 11,
          "dataset": "kmnist",
          "ms": 18.677759170532227,
          "parent_ms": 24.618782999993982,
          "correct": 9673,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.807148001245878,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 21.811634998748104,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.133875828215878,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.33887958526611,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 12,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.702335357666016,
          "parent_ms": 24.883583000018916,
          "correct": 9804,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.6893805006532148,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 22.1942024993657,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.491867141699686,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.35116767883301,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 13,
          "dataset": "kmnist",
          "ms": 18.671615600585938,
          "parent_ms": 24.692928999968444,
          "correct": 9648,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.5472750018789156,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 22.14565399808953,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.474038397503591,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.33580780029297,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 14,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.719743728637695,
          "parent_ms": 24.64502100002619,
          "correct": 9790,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.6091560007653243,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 22.035864999260866,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.316121270623171,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.35987186431885,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 15,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.703359603881836,
          "parent_ms": 25.07709399998248,
          "correct": 9811,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.583832501635925,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 22.493261498346556,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.7899018944647196,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.35167980194092,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        }
      ],
      "energy_valid": true,
      "energy": {
        "valid": true,
        "checks": {
          "finite_nonnegative_windows": true,
          "exact_matmul": true,
          "reference_j_per_tflop": true,
          "reference_tflops": true,
          "idle_utilization_zero": true,
          "idle_contexts_at_most_one": true,
          "energy_correct_vector": true,
          "energy_call_times": true,
          "energy_dispersion": true,
          "positive_net_energy": true
        },
        "rebuilt_mj_per_call": 2259.293532151003,
        "method_net_mj_before_control": 2272.962616266587,
        "control_mj_per_call": 13.6690841155835,
        "reference_tflops": 17.822243336880216,
        "reference_j_per_tflop": 8.12014184249741,
        "energy_calls": 893,
        "energy_correct": 8741717,
        "energy_total": 8930000,
        "energy_median_ms": 15.26476764678955,
        "energy_window_names": [
          "idle 1",
          "reference",
          "idle 2",
          "control",
          "idle 3",
          "method",
          "idle 4"
        ],
        "parity_checks": {
          "canonical_stored_record_exact": true,
          "literal_mj_vs_canonical": true,
          "literal_validity_vs_canonical": true
        },
        "canonical_problems": [],
        "raw_window_sha256": "3440fa424192f8fe4e868c37facbe8e8ef49514699757010acc164336f3fb692"
      }
    },
    {
      "run": 3,
      "raw_file": "run-3.json",
      "raw_sha256": "79d45b95e22cc17a1cebdc4c9c5bc48b8e85bfdab8bf97db97816426f8c8b1c5",
      "stdout_bytes": 1642,
      "stdout_sha256": "b258a87e8f7861b83458b951ef58d8828641fa7b9c22cf950a45a3026fd55938",
      "stderr_bytes": 3536,
      "stderr_sha256": "741f0f295921aed5a9f38d47ae548353d3a1b5b9eb667aff824e9ded396f482d",
      "header_checks": {
        "successful_return": true,
        "exact_source": true,
        "exact_entrypoint": true,
        "canonical_version": true,
        "sandboxed": true,
        "correct_band": true,
        "A100_80GB": true,
        "canonical_image_torch": true
      },
      "score_passed": true,
      "literal_checks": {
        "exact15calls": true,
        "exact11MNIST": true,
        "exact4foreign": true,
        "only_declared_datasets": true,
        "foreign_valid": true,
        "call1_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call2_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call3_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call4_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call5_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call6_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call7_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call8_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call9_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call10_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call11_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call12_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call13_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call14_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "call15_valid_counts_clocks": true,
        "mnist_accuracy": true,
        "mnist_per_draw": true,
        "mnist_trimmed_parent_clock": true,
        "mnist_dispersion": true,
        "holdout_accuracy": true,
        "holdout_per_draw": true,
        "holdout_trimmed_parent_clock": true,
        "holdout_dispersion": true
      },
      "parity_checks": {
        "literal_rank_vs_canonical": true,
        "stored_rank_exact": true,
        "stored_problems_exact": true,
        "stored_summary_exact": true,
        "literal_acceptance_vs_canonical": true
      },
      "canonical_problems": [],
      "ranked_ms": 22.28001066914882,
      "groups": {
        "mnist": {
          "correct": 107587,
          "total": 110000,
          "required_correct": 107470,
          "accuracy_margin_labels": 117,
          "accuracy_pct": 97.80636363636364,
          "per_draw_floor_correct": 9620,
          "weakest_correct": 9755,
          "reported_ms_mean": 18.771502408114348,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms_mean": 22.473868181189392,
          "parent_floor_ms": 22.28001066914882,
          "floor_applied": true,
          "ranked_group_ms": 22.28001066914882,
          "median_reported_ms": 18.775039672851562,
          "min_reported_ms": 18.725887298583984,
          "max_reported_ms": 18.79961585998535,
          "trimmed_kept_group_indices": [
            11,
            8,
            6,
            9,
            3,
            4,
            1,
            2,
            10
          ],
          "trimmed_reported_mean_ms": 18.770488739013672,
          "trimmed_parent_less_protocol_mean_ms": 22.071507666052177
        },
        "holdout": {
          "correct": 35431,
          "total": 40000,
          "required_correct": 6000,
          "accuracy_margin_labels": 29431,
          "accuracy_pct": 88.5775,
          "per_draw_floor_correct": null,
          "weakest_correct": 8845,
          "reported_ms_mean": 18.78758430480957,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms_mean": 22.382799999172498,
          "parent_floor_ms": 22.188862077648448,
          "floor_applied": true,
          "ranked_group_ms": 22.188862077648448,
          "median_reported_ms": 18.78220844268799,
          "min_reported_ms": 18.768896102905273,
          "max_reported_ms": 18.81702423095703,
          "trimmed_kept_group_indices": [
            4,
            1,
            3
          ],
          "trimmed_reported_mean_ms": 18.77777099609375,
          "trimmed_parent_less_protocol_mean_ms": 22.322893832190697
        }
      },
      "literal_calls": [
        {
          "index": 1,
          "dataset": "fashion",
          "ms": 18.786304473876953,
          "parent_ms": 24.884879000001803,
          "correct": 8884,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.5822169993849045,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 22.3026620006169,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.516357526739945,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.39315223693848,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 2,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.741247177124023,
          "parent_ms": 24.61940399999918,
          "correct": 9786,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.49530949947075,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 22.12409450052843,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.3828473234044054,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.37062358856201,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 3,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.78937530517578,
          "parent_ms": 25.225996000003192,
          "correct": 9780,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.9180105001631205,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 22.307985499840072,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.5186101946642907,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.39468765258789,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 4,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.795520782470703,
          "parent_ms": 24.926910999994334,
          "correct": 9791,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.8179035002484056,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 22.10900749974593,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.313486717275225,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.39776039123535,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 5,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.787328720092773,
          "parent_ms": 24.850965000013048,
          "correct": 9800,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.7355385005115522,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 22.115426499501496,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.328097779408722,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.39366436004639,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 6,
          "dataset": "fashion",
          "ms": 18.81702423095703,
          "parent_ms": 25.57036100000687,
          "correct": 8848,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 3.007842499888966,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 22.562518500117903,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.745494269160872,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.408512115478516,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 7,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.782207489013672,
          "parent_ms": 25.395889999998644,
          "correct": 9781,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.779988001468837,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 22.615901998529807,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.8336945095161354,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.391103744506836,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 8,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.775039672851562,
          "parent_ms": 24.890535999986696,
          "correct": 9766,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.952524500256345,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 21.93801149973035,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.1629718268787883,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.38751983642578,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 9,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.769920349121094,
          "parent_ms": 28.744128999989016,
          "correct": 9755,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.7910499999051126,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 25.953079000083903,
          "unexplained_ms": 7.18315865096281,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.38496017456055,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 10,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.79961585998535,
          "parent_ms": 25.00236800000266,
          "correct": 9781,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 3.121457001206977,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 21.880910998795684,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.081295138810333,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.399807929992676,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 11,
          "dataset": "fashion",
          "ms": 18.768896102905273,
          "parent_ms": 25.311337000005096,
          "correct": 8854,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.8303910024053494,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 22.480945997599747,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.7120498946944736,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.38444805145264,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 12,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.725887298583984,
          "parent_ms": 24.871207999979106,
          "correct": 9791,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.903794000844755,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 21.96741399913435,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.2415267005503665,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.36294364929199,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 13,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.761728286743164,
          "parent_ms": 25.027140000020154,
          "correct": 9763,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.5480125029371266,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 22.479127497083027,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.717399210339863,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.38086414337158,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 14,
          "dataset": "fashion",
          "ms": 18.778112411499023,
          "parent_ms": 24.758104999989428,
          "correct": 8845,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.5730315016339773,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 22.18507349835545,
          "unexplained_ms": 3.406961086856427,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.38905620574951,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        },
        {
          "index": 15,
          "dataset": "mnist",
          "ms": 18.758655548095703,
          "parent_ms": 24.622110999985125,
          "correct": 9793,
          "total": 10000,
          "overhead_ms": 2.9005199998748594,
          "parent_less_protocol_ms": 21.721591000110266,
          "unexplained_ms": 2.9629354520145625,
          "maximum_unexplained_ms": 59.37932777404785,
          "clock_gate_passed": true
        }
      ],
      "energy_valid": true,
      "energy": {
        "valid": true,
        "checks": {
          "finite_nonnegative_windows": true,
          "exact_matmul": true,
          "reference_j_per_tflop": true,
          "reference_tflops": true,
          "idle_utilization_zero": true,
          "idle_contexts_at_most_one": true,
          "energy_correct_vector": true,
          "energy_call_times": true,
          "energy_dispersion": true,
          "positive_net_energy": true
        },
        "rebuilt_mj_per_call": 2228.1759030463245,
        "method_net_mj_before_control": 2242.573844852092,
        "control_mj_per_call": 14.397941805767589,
        "reference_tflops": 18.22082177580288,
        "reference_j_per_tflop": 8.213894119597372,
        "energy_calls": 915,
        "energy_correct": 8955516,
        "energy_total": 9150000,
        "energy_median_ms": 15.313920021057129,
        "energy_window_names": [
          "idle 1",
          "reference",
          "idle 2",
          "control",
          "idle 3",
          "method",
          "idle 4"
        ],
        "parity_checks": {
          "canonical_stored_record_exact": true,
          "literal_mj_vs_canonical": true,
          "literal_validity_vs_canonical": true
        },
        "canonical_problems": [],
        "raw_window_sha256": "eb2850f43e4fb00fe9cff170a877d19ddbf8e6187b2b608a9fb0e6cd2b552e53"
      }
    }
  ],
  "parent_parity_checks": {
    "source": true,
    "raw_bytes": true,
    "passed": true,
    "valid_energy": true,
    "time": true,
    "energy": true,
    "counts": true,
    "margins": true
  },
  "parent_verification_sha256": "6f62134c007a0e096c5177825c08e16a0c0473322bd69ebd3e0bdff06af5ae91",
  "blockers": [],
  "disposition": "Exact-source initial reviewer group qualifies 3/3; score is faster than the accepted full-precision D4 baseline. All three energy values are valid, so the complete-group energy median is reportable.",
  "audit_scope": "Literal independent integer accuracy/count/clock floor/dispersion arithmetic plus canonical replay; independent seven-window idle/reference/control/method energy reconstruction. Exact source Git blob, frozen plan/harness/guard, controller and owned-app stopped-zero proof checked locally. No learner/Torch/Modal import, API or GPU call, evidence mutation, rerun or replacement.",
  "auditor_sha256": "fa8096bd1a78497ba5e1a597c665f04caf6c2a5d5f58c74ad1231f8717aad374",
  "literal_helper_sha256": "2ebcb540e9a1608c83944bf2dca538ab25619a4f7d27f58d5f70a1d51c344c93"
}
