{
  "pull_request": 113,
  "reviewed_head": "0b4a34abbb4a73927d14f7ec43f3e142a61f458d",
  "scope": "Author-supplied saved-record audit; no learner execution or new Modal jobs.",
  "source_sha256": "c6082659a49a6bd942077e359db42f28016626bb49303d68032467710d765a7e",
  "source_bytes": 17973,
  "canonical_scorer_sha256": "1bc6d8d96a776565bc70f3ccdb91be7de57187d4495b2b0437fac98f5e120064",
  "worktree_scorer_matches_canonical": true,
  "source_gate_passes": true,
  "runs": [
    {
      "file": "run-1.json",
      "raw_sha256": "c786f20ef2016ecff2605378e576acb4d8b2e573e0d2fc37cf7d9ce3da13e83b",
      "checks": {
        "successful_return": true,
        "source_identity": true,
        "entrypoint": true,
        "scorer_version": true,
        "difficulty3_band": true,
        "sandbox_required": true,
        "complete_call_counts": true,
        "valid_counts_timing": true,
        "saved_problems_empty": true,
        "reconstructed_judge_pass": true,
        "exact_ranked_time": true,
        "exact_summary": true,
        "full_energy_reconstruction": true,
        "energy_gates": true
      },
      "passed_saved_record_audit": true,
      "canonical_problems": [],
      "ranked_ms": 415.5265308119902,
      "mnist_correct": 107131,
      "mnist_total": 110000,
      "mnist_error_pct": 2.6081818181818206,
      "accuracy_gate_margin_labels": 101,
      "holdout": "kmnist",
      "energy_present": true,
      "energy_mj": 91822.43138010557,
      "energy_problems": [],
      "device": {
        "name": "NVIDIA A100-SXM4-80GB",
        "uuid": "GPU-3fd0f03b-7db0-3ca3-297f-763f2addf95d",
        "vbios": "92.00.45.00.0E",
        "driver": "610.57.04",
        "power_limit_w": 400.0
      },
      "stderr_empty": false,
      "author_validation_matches": {
        "error_pct": true,
        "ranked_ms": true,
        "energy_mj": true,
        "gpu_uuid": true
      }
    },
    {
      "file": "run-2.json",
      "raw_sha256": "b49e5e484c96e8fb382dab3a0aa936339eb3caaf0ceb53d67c367335100ce263",
      "checks": {
        "successful_return": true,
        "source_identity": true,
        "entrypoint": true,
        "scorer_version": true,
        "difficulty3_band": true,
        "sandbox_required": true,
        "complete_call_counts": true,
        "valid_counts_timing": true,
        "saved_problems_empty": true,
        "reconstructed_judge_pass": true,
        "exact_ranked_time": true,
        "exact_summary": true,
        "full_energy_reconstruction": true,
        "energy_gates": true
      },
      "passed_saved_record_audit": true,
      "canonical_problems": [],
      "ranked_ms": 422.5893144990535,
      "mnist_correct": 107103,
      "mnist_total": 110000,
      "mnist_error_pct": 2.6336363636363602,
      "accuracy_gate_margin_labels": 73,
      "holdout": "kmnist",
      "energy_present": true,
      "energy_mj": 91854.39678879545,
      "energy_problems": [],
      "device": {
        "name": "NVIDIA A100-SXM4-80GB",
        "uuid": "GPU-7635b627-c872-bacc-810e-535f1db40753",
        "vbios": "92.00.9E.00.02",
        "driver": "580.95.05",
        "power_limit_w": 500.0
      },
      "stderr_empty": false,
      "author_validation_matches": {
        "error_pct": true,
        "ranked_ms": true,
        "energy_mj": true,
        "gpu_uuid": true
      }
    },
    {
      "file": "run-3.json",
      "raw_sha256": "bb43970de80a86f9b51559eeda5be76ed9d10121fe8a4c59c0475bb3edfd5c72",
      "checks": {
        "successful_return": true,
        "source_identity": true,
        "entrypoint": true,
        "scorer_version": true,
        "difficulty3_band": true,
        "sandbox_required": true,
        "complete_call_counts": true,
        "valid_counts_timing": true,
        "saved_problems_empty": true,
        "reconstructed_judge_pass": true,
        "exact_ranked_time": true,
        "exact_summary": true,
        "full_energy_reconstruction": true,
        "energy_gates": true
      },
      "passed_saved_record_audit": true,
      "canonical_problems": [],
      "ranked_ms": 422.28705184361297,
      "mnist_correct": 107217,
      "mnist_total": 110000,
      "mnist_error_pct": 2.529999999999999,
      "accuracy_gate_margin_labels": 187,
      "holdout": "kmnist",
      "energy_present": true,
      "energy_mj": 99702.58312951335,
      "energy_problems": [],
      "device": {
        "name": "NVIDIA A100-SXM4-80GB",
        "uuid": "GPU-154db320-82e4-ef55-d21c-e2330fbda81e",
        "vbios": "92.00.45.00.0E",
        "driver": "610.57.04",
        "power_limit_w": 400.0
      },
      "stderr_empty": false,
      "author_validation_matches": {
        "error_pct": true,
        "ranked_ms": true,
        "energy_mj": true,
        "gpu_uuid": true
      }
    },
    {
      "file": "initial-no-energy.json",
      "raw_sha256": "6d22de10ae4d91bea81a8aa522d3b79f9b8ca3241c4b333e193dd1298198364e",
      "checks": {
        "successful_return": true,
        "source_identity": true,
        "entrypoint": true,
        "scorer_version": true,
        "difficulty3_band": true,
        "sandbox_required": true,
        "complete_call_counts": true,
        "valid_counts_timing": true,
        "saved_problems_empty": true,
        "reconstructed_judge_pass": true,
        "exact_ranked_time": true,
        "exact_summary": true
      },
      "passed_saved_record_audit": true,
      "canonical_problems": [],
      "ranked_ms": 417.3617281733263,
      "mnist_correct": 107113,
      "mnist_total": 110000,
      "mnist_error_pct": 2.624545454545457,
      "accuracy_gate_margin_labels": 83,
      "holdout": "fashion",
      "energy_present": false,
      "energy_mj": null,
      "energy_problems": null,
      "device": "NVIDIA A100-SXM4-80GB",
      "stderr_empty": false
    }
  ],
  "energy_enabled_passed_runs": 3,
  "distinct_energy_gpu_uuids": 3,
  "median_ranked_ms": 422.28705184361297,
  "median_energy_mj": 91854.39678879545,
  "aggregate_mnist_correct": 321451,
  "aggregate_mnist_total": 330000,
  "aggregate_mnist_error_pct": 2.59060606060606,
  "author_summary_checks": {
    "source_identity": true,
    "source_bytes": true,
    "median_ranked_ms": true,
    "median_energy_mj": true,
    "aggregate_mnist_error_pct": true
  },
  "original_local_records_and_source_preserved": {
    "evaluation-run1.json": true,
    "evaluation-run2.json": true,
    "evaluation-run3.json": true,
    "validation-manifest.json": true,
    "mlp_rms_knn_d3_specialized.py": true
  },
  "initial_no_energy_diagnostic_retained": true,
  "historical_independent_failure_disclosed": true,
  "provenance_limits": [
    "The author records do not carry scorer/runner hashes or Modal application/job identities; exact remote runner provenance cannot be authenticated from saved JSON alone.",
    "Completeness of author run history is asserted, not independently established. Four supplied repair outcomes are retained and pass; the no-energy diagnostic is correctly excluded from the energy-enabled three-run medians.",
    "The existing public review failure pertains to the previous K5-only source, which is preserved; the repaired learner has a different source identity and requires its own reviewer qualification."
  ],
  "verdict": "All three supplied energy-enabled records and the retained no-energy diagnostic are internally valid under the unchanged canonical scorer. Await root fresh reviewer qualification before merging."
}
